I've owned a Fitbit tracker for a while now, starting with the Flex and then moving to the Force when it hit the market. To say I love having a Force is putting it mildly, the only times I don't have it on me are when I'm in the shower or its charging. My issue? I'm developing the contact dermatitis. It's still in the mild, annoying stage, but I don't want to give my tracker up. I know there's a recall, I know I can get my money back, but I don't want that. I want my Fitbit Force.
I was late to the party when it comes to learning about the recall. I found out the other day (8/4/14). I don't blame Fitbit for that since I'm "news avoidance girl" the grand majority of the time. So, I dutifully requested my recall packet and started the arduous task of finding a new tracker. Are there enough of them on the market now? At any rate, I began my search, using the Force as my comparison.
I have a handful of requirements:
Altimeter - I work on the third floor and only take the stairs. I like knowing how many floors I've climbed in a given work day. Silly, but hey, makes the day amusing.
Overall size - I really don't want to be wearing something the size of an old calculator watch, or something even just significantly larger than the Force.
Overall look - while I am a geek, again, I'm not interested in a calculator watch. If that was my preference, I'd already have a smartwatch paired with my smartphone.
Sleep tracking - I have fibromyalgia, tracking sleep patterns is important to me. Helps me to better figure out how to get out of my own way sometimes.
So, I started narrowing my choices down to three contenders:
Misfit Shine - I love the look of this tracker and would love to get the Storm (dark blue) version. In the world of trackers, $100 usd isn't bad, however, I have concerns. According to a plethora of Amazon reviews, it's insanely easy to lose. While I don't consider $100 exorbitant, I also don't consider it chump change. I might reconsider if they do something about that. They do have a wide array of accessories, but they're exceedingly overpriced. $80 for a silver colored pendant style holder that has several reviews essentially stating "sharp/rough edges"? Thanks, but no thanks.
Basis Carbon Steel - this thing seems to have everything but the kitchen sink. It tracks all the usual suspects (calories burned, steps, sleep, etc), it also has a heart rate monitor built into it. The sensors are also supposed to improve the metrics for sleep, giving a theoretically more accurate picture on your sleep pattern. It hits the functionality I want, but at a higher price point, namely $150 usd. Not to mention that it looks huge and bulky, and having developed contact dermatitis from the metal on one tracker, what says it won't happen here?
The last one I'd been considering was the Withings Pulse O2 - can I just say that this thing is ugly? Yeah, it does all sorts of nifty things, it really doesn't seem to do them elegantly. It looks like you strapped a pedometer to your wrist (please let's not split hairs over the fact that trackers are pedometers with delusions of grandeur). The wrist bands are cheap looking, but supposedly can be replaced with a standard watch band. To use the O2 sensor or heart rate monitor, you have to take it out of the holder. Sorry, I like my Big Brother tech to quietly and unobtrusively monitor me with little effort on my part.
Am I giving up on my Force? Not yet. A strategically placed bandaid on my wrist, some glue on the loose sections of the wrist band, and we're back in business. Well, until Fitbit releases the successor to the Force anyway.