Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts

Friday, January 15, 2016

Weight loss goals

I've seen a lot of posts lately where people are "stalled" in their weight loss and they can't lose those last few pounds, with the number being anywhere between 5 and 20 pounds. It makes me crazy, but not for any reason you might think.

Classically, anything under 20 pounds is referred to has "vanity weight". It's also the hardest weight you'll ever lose. The body typically doesn't want to let go of it because it's very happy at the current weight. And frankly, the idea that one needs to lose that weight may be illusion. But between society telling women they should be twigs, BMI charts that don't take into account things like body composition, height/weight charts that have been obsolete since the 60's, and a fashion industry that keeps screwing with sizes, we think we're supposed to.

This is also why I have a hard time setting a goal weight for myself. The all knowing charts (sorry for dripping sarcasm on your shoes) say I should weigh around 150 - 160. I'm not sure those are necessarily good numbers. It's hard to go off sizes because no two clothing manufacturers are the same. One vendor's 12 is another's 16. Ok, that's exaggerating mildly, but you get my drift.

But to return to one of my major pet peeves with the "not losing the 5-10lbs" camp. I always want to ask them, why do you want to lose that last bit of weight? Did your doctor tell you to? Are you trying to get down to what you weighed when you were younger? Are you trying to get to a specific clothing size? Are you actually 5-10 lbs above the top end of the "recommended" weight range for your height/build? Or do you still feel fat?

Yeah, that last one is harsh, but so many of us have such skewed images of ourselves, it needs to be asked. I know I can count on my best friends to rein me in if I reach that point. They won't let me dip into anorexia. Because I'm me, I want to tackle each of my questions and the rebuttals I'd dearly love to give:

Did your doctor tell you to? - Ok, not much to balk against here I guess. Hopefully your doctor is using good science to decide what you should weigh.

Are you trying to get back to an earlier weight? - Why? You're not that kid anymore. There are realities here we all need to face. We're not getting any younger, and we're not 20 any more. A woman who has gone through childbirth is going to have one heck of a time getting back to a pre-hormonal changes weight. It's nature. But hey, if you want to frustrate yourself, rock on! ;)

For the 5-10 lbs over the top end of the recommended, my only rebuttal is, check the science. Make sure you're not looking at a flawed chart that doesn't take into account the fact that you're sporting a 6 pack now when you used to have a keg. ;)

Do you still feel fat? - Most women have a skewed view of how we look. We don't see the results of our efforts, especially if the ever lying scale isn't showing a drop in numbers. We don't see that our arms have toned up, our bellies are flat(ter), that we've become strong and sleek. It doesn't register that we've needed to buy smaller clothing. We see the flaws as if a spotlight was shining on them to the exclusion of any progress we've made. I think even the most body positive person out there struggles with this. And yes, men suffer from it too, but I can only speak from the female viewpoint.

For me, figuring out a goal to reach seems like such a lie to oneself. My health is not defined by a number on the scale. Being able to climb 14 or more floors over the course of a day without getting winded or my knees screaming for mercy. Sleeping better. Having a clearer mind and better memory. Not feeling as much pain from arthritis and fibromyalgia. NO REFLUX!! Seeing my fasting glucose drop to normal levels instead of the scary pre-diabetes numbers. These are all markers of improvement for me. Wearing a smaller size? Sure, it'd be nice, but my successes aren't depending on it. I have to admit, I wish more people felt the same.